We are supported by our audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more.
Our Pick of 3 Best Cycling Shoe Covers
Important considerations for cycling shoe covers choice:
Waterproofness
Even though many manufacturers claim their shoe covers to be fully waterproof, this is almost impossible to achieve. Water can slip through in multiple spots like the sole of a shoe or roll down from bib shorts or tights. Also, exposure to heavy rain for a few hours can penetrate even the highest quality shoe covers. Despite all of this, choosing cycling shoe covers that can stand up to wet conditions is a great idea!
Winter socks
Combining shoe covers with winter socks can help you stay warmer and expand the temperature range of cycling shoe covers.
Fit
Cycling shoe covers have to fit tight and snug. This is to provide maximum warmth by reducing air pockets and hollow spaces.
Winter shoes
You can also consider winter-specific cycling shoes if you can justify this purchase. For example, are constantly getting cold and ride a lot in winter.
10 Best Cycling Shoe Covers:
1. Castelli Diluvio Pro Shoe Covers
Positives
- Waterproof
- Windproof
- Stylish look
- Very warm
- High fit
Negatives
- Not very breathable
Castelli Diluvio Pro Shoe Covers are the perfect choice for anyone who wants to stay dry and warm in cold weather. They are made of waterproof and windproof fabric that will keep your feet protected from the elements. As a bonus, they look great.
Combined with proper socks, these overshoes are perfect for temperatures reaching freezing.
The only downside is that they aren’t very breathable, so if you’re looking for something to wear in warmer weather, this might not be the best choice.
2. Pearl Izumi PRO Barrier WxB Shoe Cover
Positives
- Water-resistant
- Windproof
- Easy to put on and take off
- Reflective detailing
- Extra fabric at the toe area
Negatives
- Don't offer the best insulation in deep winter
Pearl Izumi PRO Barrier WxB Shoe Covers are made of water-resistant and wind-protective fabric that will keep your feet dry and warm in cold weather. The extra material has been added to the toe area to make these overshoes more durable and resistant to muck.
The velcro strap makes them easy to put on and take off, which is great when you come home after a long ride. Also, the reflective detailing is a nice touch, which will make you more visible to drivers in the dark.
They are perfect when temperatures drop but might be too cold for the deep winter period.
3. Rapha Deep Winter Overshoes
Positives
- Fully waterproof
- Very warm
- Stylish looking
- Breathable
Negatives
- Expensive
Rapha Deep Winter Overshoes are a great choice if you’re looking to stay warm even when temperatures reach 20° F.
The fabric is fully waterproof and windproof, which will protect you from the elements. These are also breathable, so less chance of getting sweaty and cold feet. Also, they look great and have some reflective elements for added safety on the road.
The only downside is the price, as these overshoes are pretty expensive compared to some other alternatives.
4. Fizik Winter Shoe Cover
Positives
- Good water and wind protection
- Stylish look
- Reflective elements
- Great value for money
Negatives
- The fit is snug, so double check your size
Fizik Winter Shoe Cover is an excellent value-for-money choice for those who don’t want to overspend. They are made from waterproof and windproof materials, which will keep your feet warm in cold weather.
We also like the stylish design and reflective elements, which will keep you visible to other road users.
The fit is a little snug, so make sure to double-check the size chart before buying or even go a size up.
5. Endura Road Cycling Overshoe
Positives
- Fully waterproof
- Stylish look
- High visibility elements
- Warm
Negatives
- Very snug fitting
Endura Road Cycling Overshoes are made of neoprene material, making these shoe covers waterproof. They are also quite warm and can be used in temperatures reaching freezing, but not much lower than that.
The high visibility elements make you more visible to drivers in low light conditions or when it’s raining hard.
The only downside with these overshoes is a very snug fit, so make sure to check the sizing chart before purchasing or ever go a size up.
6. Giro Proof 2.0 Winter Shoe Cover
Positives
- Water-resistant
- Extremely warm
- Stretchable
- Easy to put on and take off
Negatives
- Not the most durable
Giro Proof 2.0 Winter Shoe Covers are made of water-resistant neoprene material and will keep your feet warm on the coldest days. They are deep winter overshoes, and the recommended temperature of use is 20° – 45° F.
The fabric is stretchable, which makes them easy to put on or take off.
On the downside, the seams tend to tear easily, so some riders complained about the durability of these overshoes.
7. Shimano S-Phyre Insulated Shoe Covers
Positives
- Fully waterproof
- Durable
- Warm
- Stretchy fabric
- Stylish look
Negatives
- Expensive
Shimano S-Phyre Insulated Shoe Covers are made of neoprene material and will keep your feet warm up to the freezing point.
They are also fully waterproof, so you should stay dry in all weather conditions. The fabric is quite durable, and you can expect a good lifetime value from this product.
These shoe covers have a one-piece and pull-on design. It is somewhat unusual, but because of this the fabric is very stretchy, and pedaling will not be impacted in any way.
The price is the only downside of this product, as they are expensive compared to other alternatives.
8. Sealskinz All Weather Cycle Overshoe
Positives
- Waterproof
- Durable
- Great fabric
- Reflective elements
Negatives
- Very snug fitting
- Not the best look
Sealskinz All Weather Cycle Overshoes are made of waterproof neoprene fabric and should keep your feet dry in most circumstances.
The construction and fabric are pretty durable and should last for quite some time. Another great feature of these overshoes is the reflective elements that will keep you visible to other road users in low light conditions.
One of the downside is the snug fit, so make sure to double-check your size before buying or maybe even go a size up if you are on the borderline. Also, we we think the look can be improved.
9. Sugoi Resistor Cycling Bootie
Positives
- Water-resistant
- Stretchy material
- Robust materials on the bottom
- High-quality zipper
Negatives
- No reflective elements
Sugoi Resistor Cycling Bootie is made of a water-repellent and fleece reinforced material, which should keep you warm during spring, fall, and in some cases, winter months.
The material itself is very stretchy, so pedaling will not be impacted in any way. They are tight-fitting at first, but after a few times, the fabric will stretch.
The extra robust materials on the bottom of these overshoes should increase the longevity of this product. In addition, these overshoes come with high-quality zippers that will remain functional even after prolonged use and exposure to water and other elements.
Absence of reflective elements is an obvious downside.
10. Rockbros Cycling Shoe Covers
Positives
- Warm
- Very budget-friendly
- Extremely easy to put on and take off
- Great value for money choice
Negatives
- Not waterproof
Rockbros Cycling Shoe Covers is the most budget-friendly product we included in this review, making them an excellent value for money choice.
These shoe covers should keep your feet warm in temperatures reaching freezing. Because of their Velcro strap design, they are extremely easy to put on and take off.
On the downside, don’t expect superb quality for this price and also keep in mind that these overshoes are not best for wet conditions as they are not waterproof.
Frequently asked questions:
1. Do I need windproof or waterproof overshoes?
The answer to this question depends on the climate you live in. For example, if the winters are dry and cold, waterproofness is probably not your top priority. Instead, you are better off looking for overshoes with extra fleece material and wind protection to keep you warm. Also, look into insulation features.
On the other hand, water protective overshoes are a must if your climate is humid, wet, and cold. However, keep in mind that fully waterproof overshoes are very hard to come by. Water almost always can find its way in, but in wet climates having waterproof overshoes is always a great idea.
2. What are cycling shoe covers for?
Shoe covers are meant to keep you warm, dry and to protect your cycling shoes from getting dirty, wet or ruined. They are mainly used during winter, spring, and fall seasons as this is when extra warmth and better clothing are mostly needed. A good pair of cycling overshoes will protect your feet from getting wet and thus cold. Also, shoe covers are great at providing insulation and wind protection.
3. Are cycling overshoes worth it?
Many cyclists find overshoes to be a necessity for riding in cold weather. Of course, you can consider other alternatives like winter-specific cycling shoes for keeping your feet warm, but they are much more expensive, and you need to be a heavy winter rider to justify that purchase.
In addition, cycling overshoes are great at protecting your shoes from getting dirty and wet, improving their longevity. This is why cycling shoe covers are a great way to save money down the road.
4. How do you put on cycling overshoes?
There are different ways to put on overshoes. Some have a zipper, while others use a velcro strap. You can also come across one-piece overshoes, which are meant to be put on like a sock.
Remember that overshoes are snug-fitting, and getting them on at first might be difficult, but the fabric should loosen up with time.
Some cyclists even prefer to put overshoes underneath their cycling tights. Supposedly it prevents water from rolling down the calves right into cycling shoes.
It is always a good idea to be extremely careful when putting cycling overshoes on, especially when getting them over the cleats area. The cleats are very sharp and can easily tear the fabric and ruin your overshoes.
5. What temperature should you wear shoe covers?
This largely depends on the climate you live in, the time of the year and how well your body copes with the cold. In general, the recommended temperature rage for shoe covers is between 30 – 55° F. Some deep winter overshoes can go all the way down to 20° F, but many riders prefer to stay inside when it gets this cold.
Luckily, shoe covers can be used at a wide range of temperatures, so you don’t need to own 10 different pairs. Also, combining them with proper winter cycling socks can expand the recommended temperature range.
6. What material are cycling overshoes made of?
Neoprene is a prevalent material for manufacturing overshoes. This type of rubber is very stretchy, making cycling shoe covers easy to put on and offering a snug fit. It also provides wet weather protection while adding insulation, which is one of the most significant advantages of this fabric. However, on the downside, neoprene lacks breathability, which can result in overheating and sweat build-up.
Alternatively, manufacturers use durable water repellent coating with nylon or polyurethane fabrics. These types of fabrics make overshoes more breathable, but they tend to be less water-repellant with time.
There are even knitted overshoes that look more like socks. They are not water-resistant and therefore sed in dry climates and not during the coldest winter days.
Why should you trust us?
In order to feature and review any products on our website we do extensive research, read user feedback, carefully review forum threads, look at search trends, brand popularity, try to actually use and test as many products as possible ourselves, and evaluate other factors depending on the product category. By doing extensive research and incorporating it with our own experience we are able to shortlist only a handful of products out of thousands of options.
We want to bring value to our readers and help them find answers to questions and buy the most appropriate cycling products. Brands and cycling professionals always try to innovate and improve to get the best possible outcome. Unfortunately, innovations and product improvements these days result only in marginal gains, but the price increase for these gains is not equally proportional. In economics, this behavior is defined as “diminishing returns”. Knowing this we focus on featuring the best value for the money products that are affordable, but at the same time have a lot to offer. We don’t want our visitors to overspend on something they will not benefit from.
